Welding types TIG vs MIG vs Electrode vs Arc
Welding types TIG vs MIG vs Electrode vs Arc

Today, due to technological advances, we can find many different types and welding processes.

Although some are simple and can be carried out in any house, other welding processes are very complex. They can only be carried out under exceptional conditions and situations.

Unfortunately, there is no single welding process suitable for all applications, so let’s start with an overview of the basic processes and highlight each’s capabilities and advantages.

Also, if we talk about the types of welding that can be carried out in any home or small workshop, we can distinguish four welding types.

Each process has its own benefits and limitations and is better suited to certain applications. No process works for everything.

These are the most common processes:

  • MIG / GMAW welding
  • TIG / GTAW welding
  • Welding with electrode / SMAW
  • Arc welding or molten flow

Other types of welding, but much more precise and not so common, are micro soldering, seam welding, ultrasonic welding, hermetic welding, projection welding, orbital welding, precision, and resistance welding.

These types of welding are not used too much.

Therefore, in this small guide, we will analyze and compare the four most common processes, taking into account each type of welding’s advantages and disadvantages. Let us begin!

Contents

MIG welding

MIG welding
MIG welding

How does MIG welding work?

What is known as MIG is metal arc welding with gas (GMAW).

The electrode forms an arc with the metal to be welded, melting with the material.

The MIG welding process has a protective gas bubble to protect the welding of the air components.

The pieces that are welded do not fuse since the welding is fed with another material, which makes it possible to weld different types of materials.

Both the electrodes and the gas that are used have to be replaced as they are spent.

What is MIG welding used for?

MIG welding has various applications, and both thick and thin metals can be welded with this method.

But for this, a good MIG welding machine will be necessary so that the power can be adjusted so that fragile and thin materials can be welded, and at the same time also weld thick steel materials.

Advantages of MIG welding

The biggest advantages of MIG welding are the following:

  • Easy to use and control the machine, recommended for beginners, since it only has one gun to learn to control.
  • It can be used in a wide range of thicknesses.
  • Aesthetically pleasing finishes.
  • It can also be used for sculpture.

Disadvantages of MIG welding

However, it also has some disadvantages that must be taken into account:

  • The materials that can be welded are limited: it is weak for cast iron and too strong for thin aluminum. The same goes for the material that is too thin or too thick.
  • It cannot be used on dirty or rusty materials. They have to be clean.
  • It cannot be used in wet conditions, as it is a somewhat delicate process.

If you think what you need is a MIG welding machine, we leave you the link to the buying guide below:

TIG welding

How does TIG welding work?

Tungsten arc gas welding (GTAW), or TIG, is a welding process that uses a non-consumable tungsten electrode to heat and melt the material.

In this way, the welding puddle is created.

This process does not use filler metal, and welding is done with a single metal. But if you want to provide filler material, you can add another rod to be welded in different materials.

As with MIG welding, a gas bubble is needed to protect the weld from contaminants. The difference is that while carbon dioxide is used for the former, helium or argon is used for TIG welding.

What is TIG welding used for?

TIG welding
TIG welding

TIG welding can be used in many materials since you can weld from steel to aluminum.

However, TIG welding has limitations in terms of the thicknesses of these materials, and although you can use it in many materials, they have to be thin to weld them through this process.

In this way, the tungsten rod used is also much thinner since this makes the welding also performs thinner and much more precise.

TIG welding Advantages and disadvantages

Here are the main advantages and disadvantages of TIG welding:

Advantages of TIG welding

The main advantages of TIG welding are the following:

  • Precise and very aesthetic welding, it is the most aesthetic welding of all.
  • Welding suitable for car and motorcycle bodies due to its thin and precise welding bead.
  • One of the cleanest welds that exist does not produce any waste.

For these reasons, TIG welding is one of the favorite welding types of experienced welders.

Disadvantages of TIG welding

However, it also has some disadvantages that you should keep in mind:

  • It is not an easy welding type. It is not for beginners.

If, after reading this, you have decided that what you need is a MIG welding machine, we leave you with our buying guide:

Welding with electrode / SMAW

How does electrode welding work?

Armored metal arc welding (SMAW) or electrode welding is one of the oldest types of welding.

Therefore, the process’s operation is effortless and very effective because the joints it creates are solid and can be used to weld thicker materials.

The electrode, which provides most of the welding material, is heated and melted, and the two parts are welded with heat. This rod, being coated, protects the weld from contamination.

What is electrode welding used for?

The greatest use of electrode welding occurs in construction since it is a very resistant type of welding.

And it is the welding process that must be used for materials such as cast iron or thick materials in general, which is impossible to weld with other welding processes.

 

Advantages of welding with electrode or SMAW

The main advantages of electrode welding are as follows:

  • Heavy welds can be achieved in thick materials, so it is the welding process used in construction.
  • It allows welding materials such as cast iron.
  • Equipment is cheaper than other welding processes.
  • It can be used in humid environments and even in the rain.

Disadvantages of welding with electrode or SMAW

After seeing the advantages of this type of welding, we will see the disadvantages:

  • It cannot be used in thin materials.
  • The finish is not as aesthetic as other welding processes, leaves scum, and requires cleaning to improve aesthetics.
  • It is not easy to learn and requires a little experience to achieve good finishes and make the bow.

Read Next – Best Electric Welding Machine 2020 – Buyer Guide and Review

Arc welding or molten flow

Arc welding or molten flow
Arc welding or molten flow

 

How does arc welding work?

Arc welding, or molten flow welding, is very similar to the MIG welding process. The two types use a cable that constantly feeds the weld but in a different way.

In this process, the cable has a flow core that generates a surrounding gas, while an external gas is necessary for MIG welding.

What is arc welding used for?

This type of welding is also used mainly for the different construction materials since it is a process for heavy and thick materials. This is why it is used for heavy steel and heavy machinery repairs.

Advantages of arc welding

The advantages of using this welding process are the following:

  • It is very efficient welding and suitable for thick and heavy materials.
  • It creates little waste, so it doesn’t take much cleaning.

Disadvantages of arc welding

This process also has some disadvantages that must be taken into account:

  • This process is not suitable for thin materials.
  • Although not much cleaning is necessary, cleaning must be done if you want an aesthetic finish.

What is the best welding? Comparative table of MIG, TIG, electrode, and arc processes

In this table, we summarize each type of welding to make it easier for you to make a decision:

MIG WELDING TIG WELDING
  • It is the easiest process to learn.
  • High-speed welding
  • Better control over thinner metals.
  • Cleaner welds can be made without slag to clean.
  • The same equipment can be used for melt flow welding.
  • High quality and precision welding
  • Fully aesthetic weld seams
  • Adjust heat input during welding
WELDING WITH ELECTRODE / SMAW / MMA ARC WELDING
  • It works well in thick and heavy materials.
  • It can be welded on dirtier and rusty material.
  • Suitable for rainy and windy conditions
  • It works as well as electrode welding on dirty or rusty material.
  • Deep penetration for welding thick sections.
  • More forgiving when welding on dirty or rusty metal.

Welding process suitable for each material

Let’s take a look at the welding process that you can use for each type of metal.

In this way, it will be easier for you to make a decision based on the projects you have in mind or the use you are going to give the welder:

METAL / PROCESS MIG ELECTRODE / ARC TIG
Welding steel X X X
Stainless steel welding X X X
Welding of aluminum alloys X X
Cast iron welding X
Chrome welding X
Copper welding X
Brass welding X
Welding of exotic metals (magnesium, titanium ..) X

Read Next – Best DEKOPRO Welding Helmets 2020 – Reviewed By Experts

Difference between MIG welding and electrode (MIG welding vs. electrode)

Since it is the question that people ask the most, here are the main differences between MIG and arc welding.

If you do not know how to choose between MIG welding or electrode, this can help you better understand the differences and distinguish the 2 virtually related welding processes:

1. Simplicity of employment

MIG welding is simple to learn for a beginner since it only has one unique element that needs to be manipulated.

With the gun, you have the materials you need to weld, and all you need to do is press the trigger to start and let it stop.

Arc welding is much more difficult since it raises the complexity of sticking the arc without causing damage to the material.

2. The materials you can use

With MIG welding, the materials you can use are limited, depending on their thickness.

They should not be too thin or too thick. Pushing a MIG welder with too much force to weld thicker materials such as melted iron could destroy it.

On the other hand, fragile materials such as aluminum will burn under the power of the arch.

In addition to this, the material used for MIG welding must not be dirty or rusty. Arc welding can be used to weld thicker materials.

3. Use inside or outside

MIG welding does not work outdoors due to rain and wind restrictions. If air blows on the metals, they will not form a solid weld.

Arc welding can be used even in conditions such as rain or extreme winds. Therefore, it is the most convenient for outdoor use.

4. The appearance of scum

MIG welding is more aesthetically appealing and, therefore, ideal for making statues.

Aesthetically, arc welding is less pleasant since it generates many sparks and debris that leave scum all over the site. The finishing touches and certain cleanings are, therefore, unavoidable.

5. Cost and portability of the equipment

MIG welding equipment is quite expensive compared to arc welding, which is partially affordable.

The arc welding device is portable in that it does not need to be fed with a protective gas and can be held in a closed place.

From welder. Online we hope the article has been useful!

Arc Stick Welder, 115 Volt, 70 Amp (Campbell Hausfeld WS099001AV)

$275.95  in stock
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

Welder Arc Welder 160Amp Stick MMA Welding Machine IGBT Smart VRD Hot Start fits Below 3.2mm Welding rods (yellow 110/220V)

$104.00  in stock
2 new from $104.00
Free shipping
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

Welder Arc Welder 160Amp Stick MMA Welding Machine IGBT Digital Smart VRD Hot Start fits Below 3.2mm Welding rods (red welder 110v)

$79.00  in stock
2 new from $79.00
Free shipping
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

DEKOPRO 110/220V MMA Welder,160A ARC Welder Machine IGBT Digital Display LCD Hot Start Welder with Electrode Holder,Work Clamp, Input Power Adapter Cable and Brush

$129.99  out of stock
4 new from $129.99
Free shipping
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

YESWELDER ARC Welder 205Amp Digital Inverter IGBT Stick MMA Welder,110/220V Dual Voltage Hot Start Portable Welding Machine

$169.99
$149.99
 in stock
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

Forney Easy Weld 298 Arc Welder 100ST, 120-Volt, 90-Amp,Green

$182.81  in stock
14 new from $182.81
Free shipping
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

TOOLIOM 195A 110/220V Stick Welder ARC Welding Machine DC Inverter Welder Dual Voltage MMA Welder Digital Display

$199.99
$139.99
 in stock
2 new from $139.99
3 used from $128.79
Free shipping
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

LINCOLN ELECTRIC CO K1170 AC225, 60Hz Arc Welder,

$632.67
$395.62
 in stock
20 new from $334.99
1 used from $495.00
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

Welder,200A ARC Welder Machine IGBT Digital Display LCD Hot Start Welder with Electrode Holder,Work Clamp, Input Power Adapter Cable and Holder(110V&220V)

$174.00
$99.99
 in stock
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

Forney Easy Weld 261, 140 FC-i MIG Welder, 120V, Green

$239.99  in stock
9 new from $239.99
2 used from $197.77
Free shipping
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

MIG155GSV 155 AMP INVERTER MIG/STICK ARC WELDER WITH DUAL VOLTAGE 220V/110V welding machine

$386.00  in stock
1 new from $386.00
4 used from $349.23
Free shipping
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

Lincoln Electric K2278-1 Handy Core

$329.99  in stock
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

Hobart 500559 Handler 140 MIG Welder 115V

$539.99  in stock
15 new from $539.99
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

2020 Weldpro 200 Amp Inverter Multi Process Welder with Dual Voltage 220V/110V Mig/Tig/Arc Stick 3 in 1 welder/welding machine

$778.00  in stock
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

Hobart - 500553 Handler 210 MVP MIG Welder,Small

$939.99  in stock
2 new from $939.99
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

SUNGOLDPOWER MIG Welder 140A Gas and Gasless Welding 110/220V Dual Voltage IGBT DC Inverter Welding Machine Including Flux Cored Wire

 out of stock
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

TACKLIFE Electric Welder, MIG/MMA Welder 20A-140A with Digital display, Advanced IGBT Inverter Technology, Electrode Holder, Work Clamp, Multifunction Adjustable Welding Current and Voltage

 out of stock
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

Tig Welder, 200 Amp HF (110V&220V) Dual Voltag TIG/Arc Stick Portable Welding Machine,2-in-1 Inverter Welder,2 Years Manufacturer's Warranty

 out of stock
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

TACKLIFE MIG Welder, 120V Flux Cored Welder, Light Weight and Portable Welding Machine with 5 Pcs Replaceable Nozzle Device, Electric Welder with 30-90Amp Adjustable and Controllable Current EWT02A

$175.97
$164.93
 out of stock

1 used from $164.93
Free shipping
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

Amico 165 Amp MIG/Flux Cord Wire, TIG Torch, Stick Arc Welder 3-in-1 Combo Weiding (165A MIG TIG Stick Arc Welder)

$549.00  out of stock
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

PRIMEWELD TIG225X 225 Amp IGBT AC DC Tig/Stick Welder with Pulse CK17 Flex Torch and Cable 3 Year Warranty

$825.00  in stock
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

2018 AHP AlphaTIG 200X 200 Amp IGBT AC DC Tig/Stick Welder with PULSE 110v 220v 3 YEARS WARRANTY

$750.00  in stock
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

YESWELDER 205 Amp HF TIG/Stick/Arc TIG Welder 110 & 220V Dual Voltage TIG Welding Machine

 out of stock
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

Eastwood TIG 200 AC/DC 20565 Welder Aluminum Stainless Mild Steel Weld

$899.99
$779.99
 in stock
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

Hobart 500551 EZ-TIG 165i AC/DC TIG Welder 230V

 out of stock
Amazon.com
as of May 29, 2021 11:10 am

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here